DIABETES IS INCREASING
A new study confirms that Vietnam veterans have an increased
likelihood of getting diabetes if they have elevated levels of
dioxin in their blood.[1] Dioxin is a powerful
hormone-disrupting chemical found in Agent Orange, an herbicide
sprayed by American forces during the Vietnam war.
Recent studies have also indicated that diabetes is increasing
among the general population in the U.S.[2] and worldwide. The
increase is especially rapid among children.[3,4] At the recent
16th International Diabetes Conference in Helsinki, Finland,
researchers said that diabetes is becoming a global epidemic. "I
think we can truly say that the epidemic is here and now," said
Paul Zimmet, chief executive officer of the International
Diabetes Institute.[5]
Diabetes is a disease of the endocrine system.[6] Specifically,
diabetes is a disorder of the pancreas, which is a long, thin
organ (roughly 7 inches long), behind your stomach. The pancreas
produces hormones that help digest your food, but the pancreas
has another important function as well: it creates hormones that
regulate your body's use of glucose, a form of sugar that fuels
most of the daily activities of all your body's cells.
The pancreas produces three hormones: insulin, glucagon, and
somatostatin. When the concentration of sugar rises in your
blood (for example, after a meal), insulin stimulates muscle and
fat cells to remove glucose from the blood and store it. Insulin
also stimulates storage of excess glucose in the liver in the
form of a starch called glycogen.
When more sugar is needed in the blood, the pancreas produces the
hormone glucagon to break down glycogen in the liver and turn it
back into sugar, which is then released into the blood stream.
The third pancreatic hormone, somatostatin, is not so well
understood as the other two but is thought to help regulate sugar
levels in the blood.
When the pancreatic system fails to control glucose properly, the
blood can end up containing too much sugar --a condition called
hyperglycemia. Eventually the excess sugar is measurable in the
urine. When a person's body is not able to use up the available
glucose in the blood, the person has DIABETES MELLITUS (Greek
words for 'honey that passes through').
There are two kinds of diabetes --insulin-dependent diabetes
mellitus (IDDM), and non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus
(NIDDM). IDDM is also called Type I diabetes, or juvenile-onset
diabetes because it usually appears during childhood. As the
name implies, IDDM requires a person to take insulin, usually by
daily injections. Ten percent of diabetics have IDDM.
The other kind of diabetes --NIDDM --does not require a person to
take insulin injections. The person's insulin levels are about
normal, but their body seems unable to make good use of insulin.
They must control their blood sugar by controlling their diet.
NIDDM is also called adult-onset diabetes, or Type II diabetes.
It usually appears after age 40, and the people who get it are
usually obese. Ninety percent of diabetics have NIDDM.
Diabetes is a serious illness. Its main effect is to cause
changes in the body's small and large blood vessels. These
changes, in turn, lead to other problems: coronary artery
disease, heart disease, high blood pressure, stroke,
deterioration of nerves and blood vessels in the extremities
(sometimes requiring amputation), blindness, kidney disease, and
death.
The symptoms of diabetes are vague --tiredness, thirst, and a
need to urinate frequently as the body tries to flush away excess
blood sugar. For this reason, many people have the disease for
years without knowing it. There are 10 million known diabetics in
the U.S. and perhaps 5 million more who have not been
diagnosed.[6]
Vietnam veterans
The new study of Vietnam veterans looked at dioxin levels in
their blood and related that to sugar and insulin levels in their
blood, and to the prevalence of diabetes and the time-of-onset of
diabetes.[1] The study compared 989 veterans who had participated
in Operation Ranch Hand (spraying roughly 12 million gallons of
Agent Orange over 10% of South Vietnam during the period 1962 to
1971) vs. a control group of 1276 Air Force veterans who served
in Southeast Asia during the same period but did not participate
in the herbicide spraying program. During manufacture, Agent
Orange was contaminated unintentionally with dioxin at a level of
about 3 parts per million (ppm).
The median dioxin level in the serum of the Ranch Hand group was
12.2 parts per trillion (ppt) and the median dioxin level in
serum of the control group of veterans was 4.0 ppt. (Blood serum
is the fluid remaining after cells are removed from blood.)
The researchers found that the Ranch Hand veterans were about 50%
more likely to get diabetes, compared to the control group. In
addition the severity of diabetes increased within the Ranch Hand
group as the level of dioxin in blood increased. And lastly, the
time-to-onset of diabetes was less among the Ranch Hand veterans
who had more dioxin in their blood. The study found consistent
increases in the likelihood of glucose (blood sugar)
abnormalities with increasing dioxin.
Among the control group, the researchers noted an increasing
likelihood of abnormally high levels of insulin in blood serum as
dioxin levels increased.
Previous studies of industrial workers exposed to dioxin had
given mixed results. Some showed increases in likelihood of
diabetes with increasing dioxin,[7] while others had shown no
such increases.[8] Six studies of three species of laboratory
animal (rats, mice, and Guinea pigs) have shown alterations in
glucose metabolism with low levels of dioxin exposure, thus
increasing the biological plausibility of the idea that dioxin
might cause diabetes.[9]
General population
As indicated above, IDDM is largely a disease of children. On
the other hand, NIDDM, is largely a disease of adults. Now,
however, NIDDM is striking more and more children. Prior to
1992, among pediatric patients with diabetes, only 2% to 3% had
NIDDM. In other words, 97% to 98% had IDDM.[3] In recent years,
however, there has been a dramatic increase in the number of
children diagnosed with NIDDM. In a study of youngsters in
Cincinnati, Ohio, in 1994, NIDDM accounted for 16% of all new
diabetes cases. Among diabetes patients 10 to 19 years of age in
Cincinnati, NIDDM accounted for 33% of diagnoses of diabetes in
1994.[3] This represents a 10-fold increase in NIDDM among
children in recent years.
Obesity has been increasing among children in recent years as
well. Between 1980 and 1990, the proportion of children defined
as obese increased from 15% to 21%.[4] The Cincinnati
researchers clearly see these two trends as linked.
The Cincinnati researchers asked themselves whether their results
could be caused by greater general awareness of NIDDM among
physicians. Or by earlier detection and referral. Or by changes
in the general population of Cincinnati in recent years. They
ruled out all these potential confounders and concluded that the
increase in NIDDM among children is very likely a real increase.
Why are more children getting this adult disease? Many
researchers have noted a relationship between obesity and
diabetes in both adults and children. Indeed, in the Cincinnati
study, 92% of 1027 children with diabetes were obese.
However, there is, so far, no known biological mechanism to
explain how the presence of excess body fat might cause diabetes.
The finding that an endocrine-disrupting chemical like dioxin may
be able to promote diabetes opens up new avenues for thought
about this rapidly-increasing disease. Perhaps it isn't fat
itself that causes diabetes --perhaps it is the toxic chemicals
stored in our fat that cause disease. It has been known for a
long time that human fat accumulates toxic chemicals. For
example, the U.S. Public Health Service has been collecting
samples of fat from humans for 20 years and analyzing them for
halogenated hydrocarbons,[10] including dioxin,
beta-hexachlorocyclohexane, heptachlor, DDT, DDD, DDE, PCBs,
trichloroethylene, perchloroethylene, 2,4-D, methyl chloride,
vinyl chloride, polyvinyl chloride (PVC), and chloroform, among
others. We each carry literally hundreds of exotic toxic
chemicals in our body fat. For any particular chemical, our fat
often has a concentration 100 times as high as the concentration
in our blood serum. It is also known that chemicals can be
released from fat to re-circulate in the blood stream during
times of pregnancy, stress, illness or fasting. Many fat-stored
organohalogens are known to interfere with our endocrine systems
by mimicking or blocking natural hormones.[11]
Diabetes is on the rise worldwide. "I expect diabetes to be one
of the major killers of the world in the year 2010," says Jak
Jervell, president of the International Dia-betes Federation.[5]
Worldwide, an estimated 135 million people have been diagnosed
with diabetes. By 2025, the World Health Organization predicts,
the number will be 300 million. "What is bothering me is that the
developing world will bear the brunt of this increase," says
Jervell. He was referring to people adopting an American
lifestyle: fatty fast food, with little or no physical exercise.
But there's another key feature of American life that we often
don't advertise: from exposure to water, food, and air, we all
take a bath more or less continuously in low levels of exotic,
poorly-understood toxic chemicals, many of which interfere with
our hormones. No doubt about it, for many people it's a wonderful
life. But the price we pay in chronic disease is high and
steadily rising.[12]
--Peter Montague
(National Writers Union, UAW Local 1981/AFL-CIO) |
| [1] Gary L. Henriksen and others, "Serum Dioxin and Diabetes
mellitus in veterans of Operation Ranch Hand," EPIDEMIOLOGY Vol.
8, No. 3 (May 1997), pgs. 252-258. Earlier studies suggesting
that Vietnam Veterans have an increased likelihood of diabetes
are reviewed in Institute of Medicine, VETERANS AND AGENT ORANGE:
HEALTH EFFECTS OF HERBICIDES USED IN VIETNAM (Washington, D.C.:
National Academy Press, 1993), pgs. 11-12, 11-13, and 11-15
through 11-17; see also Chapter 6.
[2] J.A. Fain, "National trends in diabetes: an epidemiologic
perspective," DIABETES Vol. 28 (1993), pgs. 1-7.
[3] Orit Pinhas-Harniel and others, "Increased incidence of
non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus among adolescents," THE
JOURNAL OF PEDIATRICS Vol. 128, No. 5, Part 1 (May 1996), pgs.
608-615. And see Associated Press, "Adult Diabetes Type on Rise
in Young," NEW YORK TIMES July 8, 1997, pg. C7.
[4] Carla R. Scott and others, "Characteristics of Youth-onset
Noninsulin-dependent Diabetes Mellitus and Insulin-dependent
Diabetes Mellitus at Diagnosis," PEDIATRICS Vol. 100, No. 1 (July
1997), pgs. 84-91.
[5] Maggie Fox, "World suffering diabetes epidemic, conference
told," Reuter World Service July 21, 1997. (Available in File 611
of the Dialog online database. Phone: 1-800-334-2564.)
[6] "Your Endocrine System," in David E. Larson, editor, MAYO
CLINIC FAMILY HEALTH BOOK Second Edition (New York: William
Morrow, 1996), pgs. 923-952, especially pgs. 925-936.
[7] M.H. Sweeney and others, "Prevalence of diabetes and elevated
serum glucose levels in workers exposed to
2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-P-dioxin (TCDD)," ORGANOHALOGEN
COMPOUNDS Vol. 10 (1992), pgs. 225-226.
[8] Andreas Zober and others, "Morbidity follow up study of BASF
employees exposed to 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD)
after a 1953 chemical reactor incident," OCCUPATIONAL AND
ENVIRONMENTAL MEDICINE Vol. 51, No. 7 (July 1994), pgs. 479-486.
But see also M.G. Ott and others, "Laboratory results for
selected target organs in 138 individuals occupationally exposed
to TCDD," CHEMOSPHERE Vol. 29 (1994), pgs. 9-11.
[9] The animal studies are listed in notes 16-21 of reference [1].
[10] Lenore Kohlmeier and Martin Kohlmeier, "Adipose Tissue as a
Medium for Epidemiologic Exposure Assessment," ENVIRONMENTAL
HEALTH PERSPECTIVES SUPPLEMENTS Vol. 103, Supplement 3 (April
1995), pgs. 99-106.
[11] See, for example, Robert M. Bigsby and others, "Xenobiotics
Released from Fat during Fasting Produce Estrogenic Effects in
Ovariectomized Mice," CANCER RESEARCH Vol. 57, No. 5 (March 1,
1997), pgs. 865-869.
[12] See REHW #536.
COME BEAR WITNESS TO INJUSTICE
Next Thursday, August 14 at 4:30 p.m. a silent vigil will help us
all bear witness to the huge injustice represented by the WTI
incinerator in East Liverpool, Ohio. (See REHW #255, #287,
#288, #298, #315, #320, #325, #326, #328, #341, #542.)
At 6:30 that evening, the U.S. EPA will once again hold a public
hearing to explain to the citizens of East Liverpool why their
children must attend an elementary school 1100 feet from the
stack of the largest hazardous waste incinerator in America.
On May 8 EPA released its 3800-page risk assessment on the WTI
incinerator and sent one copy to one citizen in East Liverpool.
On May 9 EPA held a public hearing in East Liverpool to take
testimony on the risk assessment that no one had seen, much less
read. Peer reviewers were given 10 days to review the 3800 pages
and send their comments to EPA. One day after the deadline for
peer review comments -- May 20th -- EPA issued the full
commercial operating permit to the WTI incinerator.
Words cannot express the outrage and disgust that we feel. Has
there ever been a government agency more arrogant or more cynical
than William Jefferson Clinton's (and Carol Browner's) EPA? Come
bear silent witness with us. At the East End Elementary School in
East Liverpool, Ohio at 4:30 pm. (Don't know where it is? Come to
town and ask.) And at the EPA public hearing in City Hall at
6:30. Be there if you can. This is one of the most important
citizen fights of this century. We must never concede victory to
the forces of evil -- the Von Roll Corporation and its corrupt
acolytes in Washington. --Peter Montague
Descriptor terms: vietnam vets; agent orange; dioxin; diabetes
mellitus; pancreas; hormone disruptors; insulin; glucagon;
glycogen; hyperglycemia; iddm; niddm; ranch hand; operation ranch
hand; cincinnati; disease statistics; mortality; morbidity;
obesity; somatostatin; wti; |